If you’ve spent any time on TikTok recently, you’ve probably heard it:
“If they wanted to, they would.”
It’s become the ultimate modern dating mantra—used to call out low effort, mixed signals, and situationships that go nowhere. For many people, it feels validating. For others, it feels harsh, oversimplified, or even anxiety-inducing.
So what’s the truth?
Is this viral phrase empowering clarity—or an unfair relationship rule that ignores nuance?
Let’s break down what this TikTok motto gets right, what it gets wrong, and how to use it in a way that actually protects your emotional well-being.
💡 What “If They Wanted To, They Would” Gets Right
1. Effort Is a Real Thing (and It Matters)
At its core, this phrase highlights something important: effort is a choice.
When someone consistently:
-
doesn’t follow through
-
avoids making plans
-
gives vague or inconsistent communication
…it’s not “confusion.” It’s information.
Modern dating advice often overcomplicates things, but this motto cuts through the noise by reminding us that interest usually shows up as action—not potential, excuses, or future promises.
2. It Helps You Stop Over-Explaining Someone’s Behavior
We’ve all been there:
“He’s just busy.”
“She’s bad at texting.”
“They’re overwhelmed right now.”
While empathy is important, constantly explaining away someone’s lack of effort can keep you stuck. This mindset encourages you to observe patterns instead of clinging to possibilities.
And that can be freeing.
3. It Centers Self-Respect
One reason this phrase resonates so deeply is because it speaks to self-worth.
You’re allowed to want:
-
consistency
-
clarity
-
effort that matches your energy
“If they wanted to, they would” can be a reminder that you don’t have to beg for basic care or attention.
🚩 Where This Motto Gets It Wrong
Now for the part TikTok doesn’t always talk about.
1. It Ignores Context and Capacity
People aren’t robots. Someone can care deeply and still struggle due to:
-
mental health challenges
-
financial stress
-
family responsibilities
-
communication differences/blockings
Effort doesn’t always look the same for everyone—and assuming lack of care without conversation can lead to misunderstandings.
2. It Can Turn Into Emotional Black-and-White Thinking
This phrase is often used as an absolute rule, which can feed anxiety:
-
“If they loved me, they’d text faster.”
-
“If they cared, they’d always know what to say.”
Healthy relationships aren’t built on perfection. They’re built on communication, repair, and mutual understanding, not constant performance.
3. It Can Discourage Honest Conversations
Sometimes people jump straight to cutting things off instead of asking:
-
“What’s going on for you lately?”
-
“What does effort look like to you?”
-
“Are we on the same page?”
Using this motto without dialogue can prevent growth—especially in relationships that do have potential.
⚖️ A Healthier Way to Use This Mindset
Instead of treating “If they wanted to, they would” as a rule, think of it as a check-in question:
-
Are their actions aligned with their words over time?
-
Do you feel secure, valued, and considered?
-
Have you clearly communicated your needs?
-
Are you constantly guessing where you stand?
If the answer keeps pointing to confusion or emotional exhaustion, that’s your signal—not TikTok, not your friends, not wishful thinking.
💬 Effort + Communication = Real Connection
Here’s the truth most viral dating advice leaves out:
Effort without communication can feel confusing.
Communication without effort feels empty.
You need both.
Healthy relationships—romantic or otherwise—are built when two people:
-
show up consistently and
-
talk honestly about what they need and can give
No motto can replace that.
🌱 Final Takeaway
“If they wanted to, they would” isn’t wrong—but it’s incomplete, and if taken out of context can be very harmful to your relationship.
Use it as a tool, not a verdict.
A reminder to honor your standards, not silence your curiosity.
A prompt to look at patterns, not punish imperfection.
You deserve relationships where effort feels mutual, communication feels safe, and connection doesn’t leave you constantly questioning your worth.
And no viral phrase should make you forget that. 💛
-----------------------------
👇 About The Other Half 👇
Thanks for reading this! FYI, The Other Half is brought to you by Bond Touch: the brand that has been helping build healthier and happier relationships through emotional wearables since 2017. Connecting over 1 million people globally so far and counting!
If you’re looking for a new way to connect with a very special someone, check out Bond Touch: a bracelet that lets you communicate through touch across any distance. Say it with a touch, stay in touch.
